Effects of Birth Order on Sibling Dynamics

It’s always fun to be born with siblings, with their games and not-so-serious fights. But have you ever wondered why the eldest tends to be responsible, independent, and protective? Meanwhile, the youngest is more playful, carefree, and social. You might think it’s a mere coincidence, but the truth lies in their birth order.

Different birth orders in a family have different negative and positive outcomes. This article discusses how a person’s birth order affects their personality, family responsibilities, and sibling relationships from childhood to adulthood. It gives an overview of how parental expectations impact the sibling relationship, why there is some misunderstanding among siblings, and how this turns into long-term sibling rivalry. 

Lastly, it provides practical solutions for how small changes in communication and perspective can prevent lifelong sibling rivalry. Learning about these patterns can open new opportunities to strengthen sibling relationships, creating stronger understanding and more harmony in the family.

How birth order influences long-term sibling relationships

Sibling relationships have a lengthy history of common experiences, offering chances for play, support, disagreement, rivalry, and mutual understanding.

Birth order plays a significant role in shaping these dynamics between siblings over time. From childhood through adulthood, the order in which one is born in a family influences their interactions, responsibilities, and personal development. 

Some firstborns are way too possessive at the beginning when a second child is born in that family, and all the attention moves away from them. But eventually, when they grow older, they’ll understand the reason behind this.

These relationships evolve based on multiple factors, such as parental expectations, personality traits, and life choices and often have lasting effects into adulthood. Understanding these influences can help individuals navigate and strengthen sibling bonds despite inherent differences and mitigate the effects of birth order. Here are some of the most important:

The impact of parental expectations

Looming large in the background, parental expectations and different treatments among siblings largely affect their relationship.

For example, most parents want older siblings to be role models. They want the firstborn to take responsibility and care for the younger sibling. They often treat younger ones with more warmth and compassion. 

This is often portrayed or seen as favoritism. The eldest feels that the younger ones are the favorite children. This eventually leads to jealousy, depressive symptoms, anxiety, low self-esteem, and other behavioral problems over the period, affecting the sibling relationship. 

A study about the perception of sibling relationships and birth order among Asian,  American, and European households found that firstborns report feeling pressured to be role models, 

Parenting styles also influence how sibling relationships evolve.

Authoritative parenting, which involves friendly relationships with children, is linked to healthier sibling interactions. Hence, children raised in authoritarian or permissive households, where strict rules and highly demanding expectations prevail, report higher levels of mutual support and understanding. 

Read more: The Vital Role of Family Routines in Nurturing Healthy Family Relationships 

Birth order effects in adulthood

The effect of birth order extends beyond childhood. It shapes personality, career choices, and long-term family relationships. Like all other changes, sibling roles and relationships change over time due to multiple factors, such as parental care, personal characteristics, and family dynamics. 

While this changes a lot, siblings are still the most important relationship. Why? Because siblings play major roles in each other’s lives. They can be playmates, companions, and adversaries, shaping one another’s growth and well-being.

As children, siblings spend more time together, playing, sharing, and trying new things. But as they grow, most of them part ways, choosing different career paths, lifestyles, and relationships. The time they spend together significantly affects sibling relationships. Although they are born into the same family, their lives change as they grow.

Read more: Sibling Ties: Navigating the Lifelong Bond as Adults

The role of birth order in shaping personality

Do you know that there is actually a psychological theory discussing the impact of birth order on personality? 

Alfred Adler, an Austrian psychotherapist, proposed the birth order theory. In this theory, the order in which a child is born and the number of siblings are related to their personality and potential.

For example, the firstborn, who gets all the attention and care from the parents, eventually has to share that with the secondborn. From this, he posits that the firstborn always develops a sense of grudge.

The following section will discuss Adler’s ideas on birth order and personality traits in more detail.

Firstborn traits and sibling interactions

Firstborns are responsible, independent, and obedient. They are mostly organized, careful, and strictly morally upright. They are high-achieving but often tend to be controlling, wanting to excel at everything they do.

Here’s what Alfred Adler proposes are the characteristics of older siblings:

• Natural leaders. They tend to receive undivided parental attention early on and take on responsible roles as role models for younger siblings.
• Family-focused and socially oriented. More emotionally available to the mother, they define themselves through family connections and may feel superior to other children.
• Prone to stress and high expectations. Firstborns struggle with divided attention after a sibling is born and often bear the weight of parental expectations.

Middle child dynamics and adaptability

Middle children tend to be in a special place within the family, caught between the first child’s responsibility and the youngest one’s laxness.

When the third child is born, more attention is given to the newborn, and the middle child is left alone or with less attention. This situation has given rise to the notion of “middle child syndrome,” a hypothesis proposing that middle children are likely to feel neglected or underappreciated.

One of their defining characteristics is that they possess negotiating and mediating skills for any conflict between siblings. This is because they grow up in an environment where they experience misunderstandings between their siblings and eventually learn to solve problems on their own. 

They are distinguished by diplomacy,  flexibility,  helpfulness, indecision, competitiveness, and loyalty. They are also big on friendship, says Dr. Kevin Leman in his work “The Birth Order Book.”

Youngest child tendencies and sibling bonds

Youngest siblings tend to possess extraordinary creativity, charm, and spontaneity.

They often grew up surrounded by responsible elder siblings and more experienced parents. Elder siblings usually complain about their relationships with their younger siblings, saying that they are constant attention seekers and nag about almost everything.

Some of the other characteristics include:

• Competition. Youngest children can feel like they have to catch up to or compete with their older siblings, sometimes even to better themselves.
• Social skills. Through their everyday conversations, siblings learn essential social skills from one another, including conflict management and negotiation.
• Unique identity. The youngest children might seek opportunities to differentiate themselves from their elder siblings and will try to find a distinct place for themselves in the family. They might become bold, have a sense of humor, and have social intelligence to position themselves higher in the family setup. They also tend to understand better.
• Learning and imitation. Younger siblings tend to imitate the older child’s behavior and language and can serve as support figures during caretaking events and stressful events.

Only children and their sibling-like relationships

Parents may not always realize that raising an only child has both benefits and challenges. Only children receive all the love and care, which can make them feel overwhelmed or spoiled. Some of the complex dynamics of a single child are:

• Maturity and responsibility. Growing up around adults, they develop responsibility, maturity, and problem-solving skills, similar to firstborns.
• Loneliness and social skills. A lack of siblings can lead to loneliness and weaker social skills, which can impact personality development.
• Emotional impact. They may feel misunderstood, and without someone to share problems with, they may become cautious, mature, or arrogant.
• Conflict resolution issues. Without sibling interactions, they may struggle with sharing, conflict resolution, and negotiation.
• Seeking companionship. They often form sibling-like bonds with best friends, cousins, or mentors for emotional support.
• Interpersonal growth. Friendships built on empathy help them develop vital social skills and companionship.

Despite this, studies have also found that growing up as an only child does have some positive effects on self-esteem, better relationships with parents, and better academic outcomes compared to children born with siblings.

Strengthening sibling relationships despite birth order differences

Sometimes, sibling birth order differences can exacerbate sibling rivalry. 

This can happen when two siblings with completely different characteristics butt heads with each other. Hurt becomes resentment over time, straining their bond even into adulthood. But with open communication, feedback, and support, they can overcome these differences instead of growing apart.

Here are some actionable tips you can follow to overcome the effects of birth order and promote harmony among siblings:

Encourage open dialogue

It is good to create a space where siblings can openly share their feelings, opinions, and frustrations. Studies also support the idea that practicing constructive resolution techniques would help in long-term sibling relationships.

Establish cooperative activities

When siblings spend time together, they tend to share many things, develop a sense of understanding, and work as a team rather than thinking only from their perspective. Cooperative activities can be games, chores, or other joint activities.

Provide individual attention

The main reason for sibling rivalry is parents showing unconscious partiality. Parents should try to make time for each child to understand their needs equally. Encourage their individuality and accept each one the way they are. 

Be a model

Children mostly learn from their parents, be it their speech or table manners. So, show them what mutual respect means. Make them experience how good communication can do wonders in a relationship and let them explore different ways to hold on to their everlasting sibling relationship.

Seek sibling relationship counseling

Counseling activities are also available for families with children who struggle to get along. These are focused on the cause of the issue and equipping them with better problem-solving skills. Several other interventions also help siblings to regulate their emotions better and prevent the early onset of rivalry.

In conclusion

While birth order significantly affects sibling dynamics, it is not the only factor. Other factors influence children’s relationships over time. Understanding this influence helps you navigate sibling relationships better, creating better adult sibling relationships.

Of all the relationships, sibling relationships are some of the most ever-lasting and selfless. So,  instead of letting the impact of birth order define your relationship, start enjoying and embracing life with your siblings, which you will never regret.

Now, take a moment to reflect on your relationship with your sibling, how it was, and how your relationship will be later on. Take proactive steps to strengthen your bond with your siblings or your children’s sibling bond.

If you want to see more resources on sibling relationships, check out the Family Science Labs. The lab uses the research of the Institute for Life Management Science to produce courses, certification, podcasts, videos, and other tools. Visit the Family Science Labs today.

Photo by Freepik